eumap.org
eumap
Monitoring human rights and the rule of law in Europe

(Un)Freedom of Movement: Migration Issues in Europe

2004/07/08

(Un)Freedom of Movement: Migration Issues in Europe. Part I. »

Freedom of movement is one of the fundamental principles upon which the European Union (Community) was once founded. The recent and unprecedented EU enlargement was, however, accompanied by a chain reaction of restrictions introduced by the EU15 to curb prospective migration from the new member states.

These restrictions would appear to fit into a general tendency across the EU to limit immigration. Workers, particularly from third countries, often feel just as unwelcome as refugees, whose rights have been continuously reduced in many EU member states.

Restrictions take place despite a widespread recognition that Europe needs to import foreign labour in the face of gloomy demographic forecasts, in the face of ageing populations and low birth-rates, and prospects of a collapsing social security system. Europe appears caught up in its own dilemma: Europe needs migrants, Europe fears migration.

EUMAP.ORG is pleased to announce its featured online publication: a diverse compilation of articles and opinion pieces on the most topical and important migration issues in Europe. Due to an extraordinarily large number of quality submissions, the new EUMAP compilation on migration issues in Europe consists of two parts.

Image © Dave Simmons.

Part I (Migration's Trends and Challenges) offers a comparative perspective on migration patterns and dynamics in selected EU member states, both new and old (Czech Republic, Germany, Italy), and taps into the rigours of interaction between migrants vis-á-vis host societies, and migrants vis-á-vis traditional minority groups.

East-West Migration in the Context of an Enlarging European Union: New Opportunities and New Challenges
Mariyana Radeva
"In the run-up to enlargement an important point of disagreement between the East and the West is the predicted change in patterns of East-West migration within Europe. The economic and social implications of the proposed free movement of labour will remain a controversial issue until the assimilation of new member states into the EU structures is complete, affecting both governments and citizens. Both those in favour and those opposed to the free movement of people after enlargement must adequately take into account the benefits of larger markets, possibilities for outsourcing, and cheaper labour."

Is Ignorance Really Bliss? Germany’s Labour Migration Policy
Anna Turmann
"Using the example of Germany, this article attempts to show how a denial of being a destination for third-country nationals and the poor regulation of current immigration policies make it difficult to assess migration levels and flows. This lack of assessment may in turn be partly responsible for the hesitation that seems to surround the badly needed reforms, causing further delays."

Migrating or Commuting? The Case of Romanian Workers in Italy: Niches for Labour Commuting to the EU
Florentina Constantin
"Focusing on the case of Romanian workers in Italy, I intend to challenge the traditional approach towards migration in the European Union. I will argue that, when analysing the situation of Romanian workers, the term "migration" becomes more and more inadequate in addressing the problem of migrant workers in the EU. Instead, I will make use of the more specific term "commuting", which international organisations and academic literature have previously used to describe short-term labour migration."

Historical Minorities and Migrants: Foes or Allies?
Roberta Medda-Windischer
"The main research question that this article seeks to analyse is whether, in contexts where immigrants settle in the territories traditionally inhabited by historical minorities, it is possible to reconcile the claims of historical minorities and of new groups originating from immigration, and whether policies that accommodate traditional minorities and migrants as allies in the pursuit of a pluralist and tolerant society are realistically conceivable."

 

(Un)Freedom of Movement: Migration Issues in Europe, Part II »

EUMAP.ORG is pleased to publish Part II of its new compilation of featured articles and opinion pieces on the most topical and important migration issues in Europe. (Part I, published earlier this month, dealt with selected aspects and trends of East-West migration in Europe.) Part II puts a spotlight on the situation of the most vulnerable and often overlooked groups in the course of migration debate, such as refugees and families/dependants of migrants that left to seek their fortunes in foreign lands.

The first two articles of the present selection address recent controversial media coverage of migration. The media coverage of migration issues on the eve of the recent European expansion has arguably done major damage to the public image of migrants from the new EU members, and may even have contributed to tightening migration legislation in some of the old EU countries. The selected articles offer two different perspectives on the European media coverage of migration: from an NGO representing a vulnerable minority group, and from a journalist.

The other two articles of this part of the publication offer an in-depth analysis of the newest EU legislative initiatives on the rights of third-country nationals. The EU's 1999 Tampere Council on the creation of an area of freedom, justice and security in Europe stated that “freedom should not … be regarded as the exclusive preserve of the Union’s own citizens.” The Council agreed a framework Common European Asylum and Migration Policy, which intended to include components such as fair treatment of third-country nationals and common asylum policy. In the five years following the Tampere Council, EU institutions adopted legislative packages on the rights of refugees and asylum seekers, and on the rights of the third-country nationals who are long-term residents of the EU. Each initiative in its own way represents a major step forward in harmonising EU policies in the area of freedom, justice and security, but each also falls substantially short of universal human rights standards.

One of the selected articles analyses the EU Directive on family reunification, recognising the Directive’s merits and outlining its significant shortcomings as regards fundamental human rights. The second article critiques the EU’s post-Tampere refugee regime in light of established international standards of treatment of refugees.

Media as Scare-mongering
Marius Dragomir
"The discourse in the European mainstream media on the enlargement has been tarred by inflation of fear towards the migration that enlargement would bring."

Who is Afraid of Migrating Roma?
Karin Waringo
"The real threat for Europe appears to be not a massive immigration of Roma from the East to the West; rather, the threat is that Europe will maintain the centuries-old status quo with Roma as social outcasts, for whom Europe's promises of freedom, justice, and security are nothing but an empty shell."

Seeking Asylum in the European Union:Is the Spirit of Tampere Present in New Legislation?
By Maria de las Cuevas Rodriguez
"In the past decade, Europe has seen a significant increase in the numbers of displaced persons, and the events in Kosovo in particular became a catalyst in developing the EU's own refugee protection regime. The 1999 European Council of Tampere reaffirmed that the EU and its member states were committed to absolute respect of the right to seek asylum. This paper will present an overview of EU legislation on enacted during the past five years following the Tampere Council."

Recent Developments in EU Immigration Law - Family Reunification Directive:Achievement or Failure of the EU Immigration Policy?
Nataliya Oliynik
"In 2003, as a the result of the Union institutions and member states’ political and legislative zeal to achieve the Tampere goals, a significant and long-awaited EU document in the sphere of immigration finally saw the light of day, the Directive on Family Reunification of Third-Country Nationals. According to its Preamble, the aim is to safeguard and protect the fundamental right to family life at the Union level. In addition, the Directive is aimed at the harmonisation of national legislation on the conditions for admission and residence of third-country nationals. This article will analyse the Directive, comparing it to the 1999 Commission Proposal for the Directive for Family Reunification and try to assess whether this document has reached the aims set and whether it is an achievement or a failure of EU immigration policy."

Image: (c) UNHCR.

 
Not logged in
(Un)Freedom of Movement: Migration Issues in Europe. Menu

Related Library Resources »

Equal Chances for Europe's Roma 2008-09-16 · EU Observer Op-ed by Dzamila Stehlikova, Czech minister of human rights and minorities, and Shigeo Katsu, vice-president for Europe and Central Asia at the World Bank. They commend the European Commission for calling the EU Roma Summit, and lay out three ways in which Roma can take a greater part in Europe's prosperity. They also point out that the state of data on the subject is woefully inadequate, and that any European policy on Roma inclusion should ...

EU-Roma Summit: words and action are needed 2008-09-15 · EU Roma Policy Coalition (ERPC) On the eve of the EU’s first "Roma Summit", the EU Roma Policy Coalition urges for a long-term strategy. "Enough time has passed, there needs to be a framework with objectives and deadlines," say Coalition members. They call on the EU Presidency to formally endorse such commitments at the December European Council. The ERPC also remains concerned with the Commission’s response to the census of Roma in Italy.

Ten Years for Media Freedom - An OSCE Anniversary 2008-09-15 · OSCE This publication gathers the main findings of the roundtable, "Present and future challenges to media freedom and free expression in the OSCE region", which was held in Vienna on 29 February 2008. The report features a wide array of contributors who outline the challenges that journalists and free thinkers face every day across the whole OSCE region: threats, physical attacks and even murder, censorship, criminal proceedings in response to "critical" comments or the denial of ...

Round & round with the Roma 2008-09-04 · Budapest Times The Olaszliszka tragedy in 2006 was a clear signal that tensions in Hungary between Roma and non-Roma require immediate attention, the Centre for Fair Political Analysis argues. It also illustrated how the Roma policies of successive governments since 1989 have failed to effectively tackle the problems. What is needed is a paradigm shift, in which the Roma issue is treated as a broad social policy and welfare problem.

The Public Broadcasting System in B-H: Between Ethnic Exclusivity and Long Term Sustainabillity 2008-09 · Open Society Fund Bosnia & Herzegovina Amer Dzihana of the Mediacentar Sarajevo analyses the political paralysis that has blocked the development of public service broadcasting (PBS) in Bosnia-Herzegovina. His paper reviews the issue of ethnic rights and evaluates the legislative framework of PBS, its reform, efficiency and competition with commercial TV, and the pending convergent, multichannel and digital environment. It analyzes the policy options available now and provides realistic recommendations.

 
 
page top
eumap.org is the website of OSI's EU Monitoring and Advocacy Program (EUMAP) and an online centre for comprehensive resources, news, and analyses on human rights and the rule of law in Europe.
Selected icons: Crystal icon theme by Everaldo Coelho